Read Paul and Elder’s book, The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking: Concepts and Tools. Pay attention to the section on critical review. Develop a set of headings based on the review criteria you find beginning on page 8. This will give you a template to use when you do critical review.
Use the Paul and Elder framework you developed to evaluate the dissertation you located in the study section of this unit. Make the Paul and Elder components your headings. Add introduction and summary paragraphs that state what is covered.